A recent posting on a private political Facebook group posed an interesting question. It came from a person who usually was known for reproducing MAGA memes. Most memes are someone else's opinions that also ring a bell with your opinions. only it articulates it better... Liberals, this meme complained, condemn people who like doing their own research and that is what good consumers do. What's wrong with that? If you are forwarding memes others authored is just that, a way to say I agree... All it does is give you confidence that someone else agrees with your opinion and likes it, too. But it may deserve a rebuttal, a response, too. This one did.
I replied to the passed-on meme this way.:"Smart consumers also know the difference between deceptive, false, and puff advertising and seek authoritative and independent information from more than one source. . The old saying: garbage in, garbage out applies here. Too bad there is not a Better Business Bureau for politics. There is not a Federal Trade Commission demanding truth in advertising for politicians. "
Assume you are now doing your research: You run across a quotation or facts, or alternative facts, an opinion, and you want to sort the nuggets from the trash. Going back to the consumer analogy, here is some advice: treat it like buying a used car:.
Buying a used car, especially from an unlicensed individual, is a tricky business. It is buyer beware. Politicians can lie, cherry-pick and twist data, and even promote just about everything they want and it is sheltered by the First Amendment. For those doing their own research in politics, it is the wild west out there, just like buying that used car from a stranger. The good news is you can always find someone or something to justify your preconceived notions when you do your "research". The bad news is there is also a bunch of junk that requires some sorting out. The sorting process is one facet of what is called "critical thinking". It takes an effort to do it. Saying what you think is not a crime; acting it out could be, Shouting fire in a crowded theater is the famous standard that limits free speech. So far, even giving false information about Covid is not a crime, but some privately owned media companies choose to ban it either out of fear of a civil lawsuit or bad public relations. Media vehicles can also pick and choose what they permit, but not the government who cannot pass now laws forbidding free speech. Planning and directing an insurrection or violent acts also limits free speech protections.. Violent acts on behalf of a cause are not protected from free speech. In dictatorships, saying what you think can also be a crime, but so far in our USA we still have a democracy. If your goal is to just make your case, to convince someone else, that is one thing., but it assumes the target your posting likes the source from which you got your information. That also requires some critical thinking and anticipation of pushback and rebuttal. If your goal is to form an opinion or to seek verification of others' opinions and facts, that requires a different kind of research and critical thinking., independence of thought, flexibility to consider and reject or modify conclusions of already held notions. That one takes some self-discipline as well as critical thinking. Back to buying that used car.
The gut feeling could be one indication and the old adage applies: Would you buy a used car from this guy? The other is asking for a report from the Better Business Bureau if the seller is a business o use whatever tools are out there...Blue books, some advertised platforms to see this car had been in a wreck, and take it to a certified independent mechanic. You may be dazzled by its shiny new red paint and squeaky clean interior, but what is under the hood and the drive train counts much. Data and opinions are important, but the source that data, or facts, need to be objective. In buying this shiny used car, you may take it to a certified mechanic for analysis, one who has no stake in whether you buy it or not, give it spin and a trial, and insist on a cooling-off period before you sign the papers. Try some of those websites that may tell you if the car had been in a wreck before or consumer reports that independently have many reviews. of that make and model. You at least may still like the car for its looks, but you will also know what trouble or lack of it you are buying. That is being a good consumer.
