Sunday, January 26, 2025

Trump challenges the 10th amendment by forcing state officials help with mass deportations and condition federal disaster aid.

The 10th Amendment may help the numerous state and local officials who have sworn to refuse to cooperate with Trump's threats to jail and prosecute them for not abiding by his demands on mass deportation efforts or who refuse to meet Trump's conditions for federal aid.  That Trump is trying to abuse his power with such demands is more evidence of his attempts to get around or ignore laws forbidding him to do it.  It is glaring proof of Trump's attempt to abuse his powers and to commit federal overreach.

Can Trump also condition federal aid to states on his threats for compliance with his wishes?  He has both threatened to commandeer local law enforcement to help with mass deportations and demanding blue states like California, which need federal assistance to recover from the wildfires, abide by his conditions and demands.

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/jan/22/justice-department-trump-immigration 

https://www.wgbh.org/news/local/2025-01-23/states-push-back-against-doj-memo-warning-officials-to-work-with-ice

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2025/01/23/trump-withhold-federal-aid-la-california-wildfires/77907699007/

It is not clear if declaring a faux national emergency will give Trump the ability to ignore the Constitution's 10th amendment, but a violation of the 10th Amendment will certainly end up in court and delay for a long period any execution. 

Denver Mayor Mike Johnston has laid out his policies on mass importation efforts in the city. He is not the only state or local official to do so: https://www.denver7.com/news/local-news/denver-braces-for-mass-deportations-under-new-trump-presidency


From a Goog;e AI search: The Tenth Amendment to the United States Constitution states that any powers not given to the federal government are reserved for the states or the people. It was ratified on December 15, 1791, and is the final amendment in the Bill of Rights. [1]


What does the Tenth Amendment do? [1, 2]
  • It limits the federal government to the powers explicitly granted to it [1, 2]
  • It protects the rights of states and the people from the federal government [1, 3]
  • It reserves powers to the states that are not prohibited by the Constitution [3]
How has the Tenth Amendment been interpreted? [4]
  • The Tenth Amendment has been used to limit the federal government's power to regulate states [4]
  • The Tenth Amendment has been used to protect states' sovereignty interests [4]
  • The Tenth Amendment has been used to protect the rights of the people from the federal government [2]
Examples of cases involving the Tenth Amendment [4]
Garcia v. San Antonio Metropolitan Transit Authority
The Supreme Court ruled that a city must comply with federal labor laws
New York v. United States
The Supreme Court ruled that the federal government cannot tell states what policies to adopt
Printz v. United States
The Supreme Court ruled that the federal government cannot force state or local officials to implement federal laws
South Dakota v. Dole
The Supreme Court ruled that the federal government cannot condition states' acceptance of federal money on compliance with certain conditions


Generative AI is experimental.

Not all images can be exported from Search.




No comments:

Post a Comment