Monday, April 21, 2025

As a country we sorely need an education in civics and the Abrego Garcia case is an opportunity.


Update 5/2/2025: A majority  are getting the message. Per a respected public pollster, 54% of Americans see Trump as a dangerous dictator. The rest think Trump should have more power to accomplish his goals. Most Americans Describe Donald Trump as 'Dangerous Dictator'—New Poll - Newsweek

Continuing with the original post:

Why does it seem eyes glaze over whenever the rule of law, the Constitution, is cited and terms like separation of powers and checks and balances are tossed around? No wonder we are about to lose our democracy. We are a country of civics illiterates.  As a country, we sorely need an education in civics, and the Abrego Garcia case is an opportunity.  Somewhere, our educational system failed us. Naturalized citizens must pass a civics test to become citizens, and according to a 2018 survey, 60% of  Americans would flunk it.  Those over 65 had learned it in school; the younger you are, the more likely you are to fail. "Those 65 years and older scored the best, with 74 percent answering at least six in 10 questions correctly. For those under the age of 45, only 19 percent passed with the exam, with 81 percent scoring a 59 percent or lower."National Survey Finds Just 1 in 3 Americans Would Pass Citizenship Test - Institute for Citizens & Scholars. No wonder the age and educational divide predict who votes for whom in any poll. No wonder we are about to lose our democracy because 60% of voters do not understand how worse it could be without it. This is a challenge for political messaging. Trump's defiance of the Constitution and the rule of law presents an opportunity for a national civics lesson. It is also important for anyone crafting a political message to take heed.   An explanation in common terms must be part of any messaging of what it means and why it is important to all of us.

Update 6/1/2025 https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2025/05/22/oklahoma-schools-teach-2020-election-big-lie-trump/83731606007/
This is not civics ; this is brain washing. of children. It is what is done in communist and fascist dictatorships. There is a good reason Okahoma education ranks 49th in the nation and is such a ruby red state. There is a correlation. (PS I was born and raised in Oklahoma and left the state after college graduating)

As part of Harvard's answer to Trump's retaliation and revenge campaign for not bowing to him, Harvard is planning to offer a free online course on American civics and the Constitution.

So here is lesson one: What the heck is due process?

We are now aware of a term we may not have learned in school: "due process".Why is due process so important? All persons in the US are protected by the 5th amendment of the Constitution. It protects us from being snatched and disappeared by a tyrannical government. That is why the Supreme ruled 9 to 0 that migrants are covered ..including Abrego Garcia. It is fundamental to our personal freedom from fear of an overpowering "King", tyrant, or dictator. The Abrego Garcia case is a learning opportunity.

The Google AI definition of due process: The Fifth Amendment's Due Process Clause guarantees that the federal government cannot deprive individuals of life, liberty, or property without following fair legal procedures. This includes providing notice, a hearing, and a neutral decision-maker when the government is taking action that affects those fundamental rights. The Due Process Clause also limits the government's power to interfere with certain fundamental liberties, regardless of procedures followed. 

If you are ever accused wrongfully of a crime or even disobey a tyrant ..you would be especially grateful for it. If Trump succeeds in defying it..the precedent is set that the due process clause has no teeth and therefore, we all are no longer protected by the due process clause. It is unenforceable no matter how a court rules that it is Constitutional in this case. This is why the Abrego Garcia case and Trump's defiance of court rulings have the makings of a Constitutional crisis. Without adherence by all to court rulings, like them or not, the Constitution is just a piece of paper that once had importance in history.

Lesson number two: The rule of law still rules. It is being challenged by the rule of Trump as Trump demands judges whose judgment he does not like to be impeached, and he tries to get around obeying court orders by pulling a stunt that looks like criminal contempt of a judge's order. For example, in the Abrego Garcia incident. Judge just found probable cause Trump did in this flight of the night incident to avoid complying with court order. "those individuals were on planes being flown overseas, having been spirited out of the United States by the Government before they could vindicate their due-process rights by contesting their removability in a federal court, as the law requires." We have not heard the end of this story.  There will be a full-out trial of the stunt, and if the Trump admin. is found guilty, someone may go to jail over this. https://www.npr.org/2025/04/16/g-s1-60696/judge-contempt-alien-enemies-act   
Update 5/1/2025 : https://www.newsweek.com/trump-appointed-judge-hands-migrants-legal-win-against-president-2066830   and upholds the right of immigrants to protect their due process by objecting to the application of the alien enemies act to their cases.







Per Google AI 6/1/2025  In rankings related to K-12 education, Oklahoma generally performs poorly, often being ranked near the bottom. Specifically, U.S. News & World Report and The Annie E. Casey Foundation's Kids Count report place Oklahoma 48th and 49th respectively in educationWalletHub's study also ranks Oklahoma as having one of the worst public school education systems. 





Like
Comment
Share

No comments:

Post a Comment